Skip to content

review requests

How GitHub’s Re-request review button works, and why it is missing or does nothing

Othman Shareef · November 22, 2026 · 5 min read


To re-request a review on GitHub, open the pull request, find the reviewer under Reviewers in the right sidebar, and click the sync icon next to their name. Its label is “Re-request review”. The icon is for someone who has already reviewed, and you need write access to the repository to use it. I’ve lost time hunting for it on pull requests where the reviewer simply hadn’t reviewed yet, so that’s the first thing to check.

How re-request review works

GitHub’s docs on requesting a review describe one step: after your pull request is reviewed and you make changes, go to Reviewers in the right sidebar and click the sync icon next to the reviewer whose review you want. That makes them a requested reviewer again.

A request ends when the reviewer submits. The REST docs say that once a requested reviewer submits a review, they are no longer a requested reviewer. Their pull request drops out of their review-requested: search, and re-requesting puts it back in.

Why is the re-request review button missing?

  • The reviewer has not reviewed yet. Their first request is still open, so there is nothing to re-request. Nudge them in a comment instead.
  • You lack write access. A contributor from a fork usually has none, so they have to ask in a comment.
  • The request went to a team. With auto assignment on, GitHub removes the team as a reviewer and requests a subset of its members in its place. Re-request the person who reviewed.

When the reviewer is a code owner

Per About code owners, a code owner gets a request only if they have write permission, and a team owner must also be visible. GitHub reads CODEOWNERS from the base branch, skips lines with invalid syntax, and assigns no owner when the user or team does not exist or lacks access. On a draft pull request, code owners get no request until it is marked ready for review.

When Require review from Code Owners is on and a team owns the file, the team request stays even with auto assignment. The individual request appears next to it, and the team is removed once that person reviews. If the block that follows is “Code owner review required”, see how to unblock code owner review.

Re-requesting without the button

  1. Run gh pr edit <number> --add-reviewer <login>. The GitHub CLI manual says the flag adds or re-requests reviewers by their login.
  2. If a review requesting changes is blocking the merge and its author is away, someone with write access can dismiss the review with a comment saying why. More on that in our guide to requested changes.
  3. If you lack write access, ask in a comment on the pull request and mention the reviewer by name.

I re-request as soon as I push the fixes, and I reply on each thread first so the reviewer knows what changed, and they can read only what changed since they last looked. On the reviewer side, review request filters keep re-requested pull requests from getting lost. In Pyor, Request a reviewer sits in the pull request header, and each row in a pull request list has Request review in its options menu.

Frequently asked questions

Who can re-request a review on GitHub?

Anyone who can request a review, which GitHub ties to write access on the repository. A pull request author without write access, such as a contributor from a fork, cannot re-request and has to ask in a comment instead.

Why is there no Re-request review icon next to a reviewer?

GitHub shows the sync icon for a reviewer who has already reviewed the pull request. If the reviewer has not reviewed yet, their request is still open and there is nothing to re-request. You also need write access to request reviews, and a team request may have been swapped for a person by auto assignment.

Can I re-request a review from the command line?

Yes. gh pr edit with --add-reviewer and the reviewer’s login does it. The GitHub CLI manual describes the flag as adding or re-requesting reviewers by their login, so it works for someone who already reviewed.

Review your next PR in Pyor.

Pyor’s Inbox collects every comment written at you, and saved views keep the PRs you care about in one list. Free for individuals, and it talks to GitHub straight from your machine.